- Assets are not responding to money printing
- Break even rates signal a risk off environment
- US Dollar net long positioning at record levels
The selling pressure remains in risk assets, despite modest recoveries in certain asset classes. While US equities staged a powerful reversal on Monday, Crude Oil is still moving lower. Gold is also giving up its gains. Treasuries are sitting near all time record high prices, while the US Dollar is flirting with its resistance at 82. The bottom line still remains the same: investors are selling risk due to possibility of a disorderly default in Eurozone, triggered by Greece as the first domino. Nothing has been done, announced or hinted by authorities yet and risk off trades are very crowded. Short squeeze could occur.
Economic Data
Nothing new to report.
Equity Markets
Away from the the shorter term buying opportunity currently present in the equity markets, due to oversold levels and high bearish sentiment, I want to point investors to a warning flag in the whole risk asset space. The chart below shows that major global equity indices have currently failed to march higher, despite large amounts of liquidity, money printing, rate cuts and stimulus promises around the world. Many investors seem to be dumbfounded as to why I've turned bearish "all of a sudden", while I'm dumbfounded as to why many investors, some of which I respect a lot for their skills, "still remain bullish".
They say bull markets climb a wall of worry, while bear markets slide a slope of hope. There is always a amazingly strong argument as to why one should stay bearish at the bottom and contrary to that also stay bullish at the top. Today, this argument comes in the form of investors belief based on their recent conditioning. Since March 2009, majority have now become trained to listen and trust into central bank activities, so hardly anyone is getting "too bearish" anymore. This is perfectly illustrated by the Investor Intelligence Survey chart below. While there is a certain amount of pessimism within equities, as they have sold off by, majority are not really bearish or panicking to mark a true bottom. It seems that investors are clam or even better put... complacent. They hope the central banks will save the day.
Whatever the problem and whatever the risk, we know central banks stand ready to act, right? They told us that. As an aside note, I have actually created an email folder, where I place emails from every investor I talk that has mentioned something similar to the following quote: "central banks will not let things get out of control". Believe me, it is currently the most popular folder in my inbox. In my opinion, central banks can only postpone the crisis, not prevent it. And they have been doing their job posting it with QE2, Operation Twist and LTROs. I am pretty sure they will try to post pone it again with QE3 and/or another LTRO. We will find out soon enough, but more importantly - will it work? The quote in the chart below is from a great market technician by the name of Tom McClellan. It was said in early 2011, as Russell 2000 was storming ahead to new highs. If we were to apply the same wisdom to today's price action, we can see that something is not right within the market environment. If there is plenty of liquidity (apparently), with central bank program after program, so why aren't small caps responding?
I've stayed bullish for as long as possible in this cyclical bull, but now cracks within the market are starting to appear left, right and centre. In a bull market, one is meant to stay bullish until there is a sign of an end in both the business cycle and the market cycle. Jesse Livermore was quoted saying that a 100 years ago and it is still true today. During last years market crash and European turmoil, I called the bottom in equities on October 04th and insisted that a recession will not occur. I remember one very popular blogger put forward an outlook that 2011 was going to be the worst bear market ever in financial history - now he thinks equities, as well as all other risk assets, will rise into 2013/14 and no recession will occur.
For me, the wall of worry has disappeared. Equity revenues have completely recovered, earnings are now at record highs and gross profit margins are at never before seen sky high levels. Personally, all I see is hope. Hope of central bank intervention, hope that Greece doesn't default, hope that China stimulates and hope of further rise in equity earnings. No investor should be blamed in this uncertain and volatile time. It is hard out there. My outlook here is bearish on almost all risk assets and I could be just as easily wrong as I am right. But, in my opinion, the market is talking to us. Wrong or right, those who can understand its code, can prepare for the worst, but still hope for the best.
Please remember that this is a secular de-leveraging cycle and capitalism / free market in the West is trying to write off bad debts, starting with Greece. Politicians and central bankers are not letting the free market operate and with excess liquidity measures (money printing programs) they are only kicking the can down the road. However, eventually the free market will force its way in, but the longer we postpone it, the worse it will be. A default of some type is coming sooner, rather than later. What I am trying to say is that despite QEs and LTROs, risk assets seem not to be responding anymore, as majority are failing to make new highs. Be very careful!
Whatever the problem and whatever the risk, we know central banks stand ready to act, right? They told us that. As an aside note, I have actually created an email folder, where I place emails from every investor I talk that has mentioned something similar to the following quote: "central banks will not let things get out of control". Believe me, it is currently the most popular folder in my inbox. In my opinion, central banks can only postpone the crisis, not prevent it. And they have been doing their job posting it with QE2, Operation Twist and LTROs. I am pretty sure they will try to post pone it again with QE3 and/or another LTRO. We will find out soon enough, but more importantly - will it work? The quote in the chart below is from a great market technician by the name of Tom McClellan. It was said in early 2011, as Russell 2000 was storming ahead to new highs. If we were to apply the same wisdom to today's price action, we can see that something is not right within the market environment. If there is plenty of liquidity (apparently), with central bank program after program, so why aren't small caps responding?
I've stayed bullish for as long as possible in this cyclical bull, but now cracks within the market are starting to appear left, right and centre. In a bull market, one is meant to stay bullish until there is a sign of an end in both the business cycle and the market cycle. Jesse Livermore was quoted saying that a 100 years ago and it is still true today. During last years market crash and European turmoil, I called the bottom in equities on October 04th and insisted that a recession will not occur. I remember one very popular blogger put forward an outlook that 2011 was going to be the worst bear market ever in financial history - now he thinks equities, as well as all other risk assets, will rise into 2013/14 and no recession will occur.
For me, the wall of worry has disappeared. Equity revenues have completely recovered, earnings are now at record highs and gross profit margins are at never before seen sky high levels. Personally, all I see is hope. Hope of central bank intervention, hope that Greece doesn't default, hope that China stimulates and hope of further rise in equity earnings. No investor should be blamed in this uncertain and volatile time. It is hard out there. My outlook here is bearish on almost all risk assets and I could be just as easily wrong as I am right. But, in my opinion, the market is talking to us. Wrong or right, those who can understand its code, can prepare for the worst, but still hope for the best.
Please remember that this is a secular de-leveraging cycle and capitalism / free market in the West is trying to write off bad debts, starting with Greece. Politicians and central bankers are not letting the free market operate and with excess liquidity measures (money printing programs) they are only kicking the can down the road. However, eventually the free market will force its way in, but the longer we postpone it, the worse it will be. A default of some type is coming sooner, rather than later. What I am trying to say is that despite QEs and LTROs, risk assets seem not to be responding anymore, as majority are failing to make new highs. Be very careful!
Bond Markets
The chart above shows US Treasury Break Even rates over a ten year maturity, which is a measure of expected inflation within the system by market participants. It is also a great measure of risk on and risk off trends. As we can see right now, inflation expectations are falling, which means deflation trade is dominating. Equities, commodities and foreign currencies have all taken a beating since March of this year. So far, every single deflation trade / risk off trend has been paused by central bank action. Fundamentals are bad as debt levels continue to grow from 2007 levels, but the can is being kicked further and further down the road. As inflation expectations fall, Ben is most likely getting an itchy trigger finger. Is QE3 on its way and more importantly will it work beyond the short to medium term sugar rush?
Currency Markets
According to the COT report on Friday, cumulative net long USD positions have now reached record bullish levels. With almost 28 billion dollars betting on the greenback, this is the highest bullish position since at least 1999. Hedge funds are shorting the Euro at record positioning, while also remaining net short the Yen and the Franc. Bullish positioning can be seen in the Loonie as well as in the Pound, while commodity currencies like Aussie and Kiwi have seen major reductions of net longs.
Recent Merrill Lynch currency survey I received, which came out on 14th of May, showed that EUR/USD positioning is now at historical extremes. This is what the newsletter went onto say:
Recent Merrill Lynch currency survey I received, which came out on 14th of May, showed that EUR/USD positioning is now at historical extremes. This is what the newsletter went onto say:
"The net long in USD vs net short in EUR has reached a survey high. Last month’s move was driven by a significant increase in USD longs, this month’s change resulted from a considerable increase in EUR shorts. April’s increased optimism could be rationalised by fading QE3 expectations, this time round, the Greek election results have been the dominant driver. While the net percentage of investors expecting Greek debt restructurings has declined from 55% to 50%, 15% of investors now expect two or more countries to restructure from 9% a month ago."
Finally, last weeks currency article also showed that Public Opinion is very very high on the Dollar. I still hold a core position in Silver and do not own any US Dollars at present. From a contrarian point of view, I believe all risk assets have a chance to create a major short covering rally, if a catalyst is given (money printing, another bailout, more Chinese rate cuts, etc etc). If the short squeeze occurs, I will evaluate further.
Commodity Markets
Nothing new to report.
Credit Markets
Nothing new to report.
Recommandations
- I bought some S&P 500 Calls on Monday as the rally started. That could have been capitulation from the short term breadth, sentiment and technical indicators. Therefore, after a re-test of lows a recovery rally could start. However, I believe main trend is down, so eventually I want to short equities.
- I bought Silver Calls mid last week, so I will not be doing anything in the PMs market for now. My further action depends on Western central bank further actions. Weak action will make me reduce my core holdings and close out Calls.
- Finally, I am looking long and hard at all Agricultural commodities. I believe the bull market will resume soon. My watch list has been Wheat Calls & Softs ETF, but I am considering just buying the overall sector through RJA once again. I still have not done anything yet and I might not until selling pressure globally eases.







Best line in the article - I forgot all about that call.
ReplyDelete"I remember one very popular blogger put forward an outlook that 2011 was going to be the worst bear market ever in financial history - now he thinks equities, as well as all other risk assets, will rise into 2013/14 and no recession will occur."
Tiho. You think outside the box and that is why I come back to read your blog. What an extraordinary article. Amazing how to see indices not performing well despite LTRO. It does not even matter if you are right, the underlying theme is hit spot on: prepare for the worst, hope for the best. That is what my coach use to say in high school. - Thomas
ReplyDeleteI think we are now on the pre Second World War timeline of a recession and minor bear every 3-4 years...without credit creation to extend it out.
ReplyDeleteI would guess Obama would at least like to get to the elections. But at some point I think the CB's will just give up and let the warmth of the market wash all over their sleepy heads.
That II chart just opened my eyes... I'll throw the idea: can market complacency be seen on it? Something like Bears in the 20-30 ("low") range with bulls below 40 (also "low").
ReplyDeleteTiho, I tried to find the data series of the II chart but couldn't find it. So I used my Paint skills to overlap SPY and your chart... but it's a mess :) So, could you, please, make a chart with something like the spread between bears/bulls (a 3-4 week MA) overlapped to SPY (maybe also a 3-4 week MA) to see if it signals complacency? Thanks!!
Do you, other readers, use any valuable market complacency indicators?
I like the mother of all reversal day action on October 4th 2011 so I eagerly await for a similar day sometime in the future before I buy $SPX.
ReplyDeleteI also eagerly waiting for any hints of further QE from Ben B.
Until then, I stay away from any risk trades because there are "legitimate" concerns out there.
HI Tiho,
ReplyDeleteDo you know and have any idea,when was the last time commodities and equities moving in different direction.....meaning to say negatively correlated.It seems now,most of the time both move in tandem,albeit in different percentage changes.Would be really of high help if you can provide answer to this and if possibility with charts to it.Many thanks to it in advance
Thomas - thank you for the nice comments.
ReplyDeleteHotairmail - I have a feeling politicians are trying hard to keep this recovery going and to make it through elections as well. However, a Debt Crisis cannot be solved with more money printing loans over 3 years (LTRO), which is essentially more debt, as you well know yourself. Soon enough liquidity measures will not help kick the can down the road and than a real default will occur!
Marc - a chart of S&P 500 vs Investor Intelligence Bull Bear Ratio updated as of yesterday, can be seen by clicking here. I hope that helps you out. I do not use any 3 or 4 week MAs, because II Survey is not a volatile reading like AAII. I'd argue that newsletter writers are complacent here because:
- record profit margins and record earnings might not be able to meet further bullish expectations
- despite S&P hitting 1,420 on the last major rally, bad internal breadth readings signal weak bull market
- relaying on central bankers to extend the market rally might not do the trick anymore
futures88 - please click on this chart. It shows you the correlation between equities and commodity prices since 1915. As you can see there have been periods in time when commodities moved opposite to equities, but more often than not, they tend to correlate to equities at leads in a modest amount. I hope that answers your question. Finally, as of 2008, the positive correlation was highest since 1920s.
thanks Tiho.......appreciate it very much....reason i m asking because i think commodities is still in bull trend market whereelse i m not too sure on equities .From what i can see Dow jones and s&p market is trading above it moving average 200(which been used to differentiate long term trend) while majority of commodities already been trading below their respective MA200.
ReplyDeleteYou are welcome. I also believe commodities are in a bull market, but of secular long term nature. Having said that, currently commodities are in a cyclical bear market as the perfect storm of events are occurring.
DeleteSlowing Asian economy has seen fall in demand, while the Fed has paused its QE program strengthening the Dollar. Finally, investors are fearful of systematic Eurozone risks and are therefore selling risk assets and last but not least, banks like MF Global, JP Morgan or anyone else who is in trouble and being investigated, are liquidating positions and adding to the selling pressure. Like I said... a perfect storm of events against commodities! :-)
Tiho. Great points as always. I remember 2008 when crude went from 150 down to (was it $30's) and then retraced nearly 60%). This last liquidation push down in commodities could really set the table for a never-before-seen run. Cheers
DeleteA lot of European economic data just came out and it is a total disaster:
ReplyDelete- German GDP @ 0.5%, expectations @ 0.5%
- French Business Survey @ 93, expectations @ 95
- French Manufacturing PMI @ 44.4, expectations @ 47.0
- French Services PMI @ 45.2, expectations @ 45.7
- German Manufacturing PMI @ 45.0, expectations @ 47.0
- German Services PMI @ 52.2, expectations @ 52.0
- Dutch Unemployment Rate @ 6.20%, expectations @ 6.00%
- Dutch Business Confidence @ -5.00, previous @ -3.30
- German Ifo Business Climate Index @ 106.9, expectations @ 109.4
- Eurozone Manufacturing PMI @ 45.0, expectations @ 46.1
- Eurozone Services PMI @ 46.5, expectations @ 47.0
First of all we can see that European economic data in recent hours that just came out, pretty much disappointed economists across the board. Regardless of weather you think the government statistics are correct or not (to be honest with you they are probably much worse than reported as all governments always "edit" stats), the overall trend in the numbers is weakening and therefore European recession is intensifying. There is a big risk that US and Asia will now be affected. Since EU economy is just as large as the US, once EU catches a flu, it could spread it across the world.
However, to refocus on the short term horizon, it is possible to assume that recent sharp sell off in May in risk assets could now be attributed to a lot of the data above (plus other bad economic data in the US and Asia). In other words, since the market is a discount mechanism, we could have already discounted majority of the bad news for now. Risk assets everywhere are oversold and sentiment is very bearish. Keep in mind that a multi-week rebound could now occur on any upside surprises with economic data or a catalyst by central banks / governments around the world.
Gold Miners are currently one asset class bucking the trend down, which is a positive for PMs investors, at least in the short term.
Thanks for the chart Tiho. It doesn't seem useful to detect tops but "excesive complacency" may be visible... I see most significant corrections are signaled with the spread below the SD (ie: panic mode) and this signal is not visible on the current correction altought it is a significant one (ie: people is not worried about the correction as they should... so they are being, maybe, too confident!).
ReplyDeleteThanks again!
Hon Hai's (Foxconn) Terry Gou forecasts tough times.
ReplyDeleteTerry Gou, who controls an electronics manufacturing empire that employs more than one million workers in China, predicted tough times ahead for the world due to economic turmoil.
Gou, chairman of the Hon Hai Group, said that judging by information from the group's European retail chain partner, the situation in Europe is “really bad,” according to a magazine interview published yesterday.
According to the Chinese-language interview, he also predicts that conditions in the United States will definitely be bad in 2013 after the presidential election.
Gou said he thinks that the U.S. government will sooner or later adopt a third round of quantitative easing (QE3) to boost the economy. He said that if U.S. President Barack Obama's contender mounts a strong presidential campaign, the QE3 will come sooner.
Source and complete story:
http://www.chinapost.com.tw/business/company-focus/2012/05/24/342115/Hon-Hais.htm
Thank you Edwin. I have heard quite a lot of stories from China about a more serious decline in economic activity. I have also shown that there is evidence that economic activity is picking up too. It is hard to figure out what is going on in China, but I have to say one thing is certain. Industrial commodities like Copper and Crude Oil are not in a decline because of Greece. Greece is totally irrelevant consumer of these commodities, while China is the prime consumer. That tells us something!
DeleteTiho...I want to clarify that while I am hiding in the bunker, I look into my periscope 24/7 for sign of a reversal. It is more exciting and rewarding to do the risk trades.
DeleteI love your passion...
It's been a while dude :-)
ReplyDeleteNice post dude.
You'll soon have to fly over here to pay your pints!
Tiho, you may want to consider something like Disqus (disqus.com) to try to lower the spam that's getting in those days :)
ReplyDelete