Thursday, January 19, 2012

Portfolio Upate: Long Swiss Franc

Portfolio Update
Before I get into the Swiss Franc post, I would like to update the funds performance as well as short term issues we have been constantly emailed about. Majority of the funds cash in now deployed in investments, which means the opposite of majority of 2011. As the NAV grows due to expended partner inflows, we will be looking at allocating more cash towards sound investments, but for the time being the fund holds Agriculture (RJA), Physical Silver (PSLV) (where we have added slightly to our position) and the new addition Swiss Franc (FXF).
The funds performance [updated as of 21st of Jan 2012] has been quite volatile to start of with. It is due to our slightly leveraged position of Physical Silver Trust (PSLV). There has been a huge rally as we bought at the recent intermediate bottom. That sent the funds overall performance to a high return. However, we understood that Mr Sprott was planning to do a second offering and reduce the premium, which meant that the Trust price was overvalued has not yet found equilibrium.

We have received many many emails warning us of this issue and we appreciate that very much so. Nonetheless, this issue does not concern us as we are not traders with short term perspectives. As we are expecting the ratio of Gold to Silver to come back to its historical norm of 16 to 1, we also understand that the current true value of Silver is around $100 as Gold trades around $1,600. Therefore a premium of 15% does not really concern us much.

We are much much more worried about being invested into "real" Silver vehicle that has liquidity of a stock. On top of that, as opposed to Comex "paper" Silver, which has about 5% physical backing, we rather own something that is actually stored in a vault in Canada. In the long run we can expect geopolitical problems in Middle East, European Sovereign Defaults and ongoing global currency debasement; so an investor has to make sure the asset bought will actually do what is expected.

Long Swiss Franc
We don't like currencies in general, as we think Western countries are in the process of ongoing debasement to ease the debt burdens on societies. When we look at the global currency picture, we definitely do not like the US Dollar first and foremost, followed by other sick major currencies like British Pound, Japanese Yen and the European Euro. And while we are currently contrarian bullish on the Euro, as everyone falls in love with the US Dollar, an even better currency we do like right now is the Swiss Franc.
Swiss Franc is currently pegged to the Euro by the order of the Swiss National Bank. Therefore, the current correction in the Franc, which has been a major one in this secular bull market against the US Dollar, has been manifested in part due to a central bank decision. Now, if you are a keen student of financial history, you would have learned that central banks almost always tend to be wrong in their decisions to stem currency appreciations and maintain pegs, so we are prepared to take a bet that the current one will also end up being a total disaster. So why did we buy the Franc now, as opposed to before?
Well first of all, we are super bearish on the US Dollar right now. From a contrarian point of view, we can see that investors hold record net shorts on the Euro as of last Friday. Since the Franc is pegged to the Euro, a rise in the Euro will also mean an equal or slightly better rise in the Swiss Franc. So in other words, the Swiss Franc should do at least as well as the Euro does, but possibility much better, because Safe Haven currencies like the Franc tend to thrive in ZIRP environment.
On top of that, there are now shorts on the Swiss Franc futures contracts as well. We think that the current Dollar rally is almost complete, similar to what we saw in 2008 and 2010 spikes. Therefore, the current fall in the Franc, while speculators remain net short, is a great buying opportunity and a great investment.
After a dramatic fall since early August, there isn't a bull in sight when it comes to the Swiss Franc using the Public Opinion. To be quite honest, the sentiment on the Franc is now as low as we have seen it since at least 2005 - and one of the lowest in a decade. As a matter of fact, the Public Opinion on the Euro and the Pound is at a multi year lows too, which is also a great confirming signal that the Dollar rally is due to end very very shortly (more on that later in the week in Part II of the currency post).
Furthermore, I found it very interesting to see a huge Short Interest Ratio on the Swiss Franc ETF (FXF). Ever since the Franc topped in August, investors have gone mad with shorting the currency as if it is going to be a sure bet all the way down to zero. I have a feeling that these short positions will shortly be super squeezed, just like the ones in the Euro COT report (chart above).

Summary
All in all, buying Swiss Franc is very similar to buying Silver. Essentially, it is a bet against the US Dollar - the most fundamentally flawed currency around right now. On top of that, just like Silver few weeks ago, the Franc is very much hated right now and there is above average chance of a rally around these levels. Wish us good luck!

Investment Summary
Date: 18th of January 2012
Investment: Currencies
Product: FXF ETF
Entry: USD $104.78
Percentage of NAV: 11%

23 comments:

  1. Tiho:

    CEF holds gold and silver in a Canadian vault.
    SLV etf of silver, too.
    Please keep the Fosters on ice.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Tiho:

    CEF holds gold and silver in a Canadian vault.
    SLV etf of silver, too.
    Please keep the Fosters on ice.

    ReplyDelete
  3. In this context (your currency outlook) buying CHFJPY sounds like a better option maybe?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous #1 - I don't want Gold. Even though it will go higher, it first could correct more or at least consolidate. Gold is twice the record of 1980, while Silver is extremely depressed and about 40% below the 1980 record. Since 1980 population has doubled, GDP has gone up 5 times, Dow Jones is up 12 times, Gold has more than doubled and Silver is down 40%. So I just want Silver for now and I don't want Comex Futures (which I use for trading only) nor do I want SLV, which is pretty much the same.

    Anonymous #3 - I think Japanese Yen will go higher before it tops, and while I think Yen is an awful currency, it is much much better than the Dollar. SO I rather buy Franc Dollar than, Franc Yen for myself. Personally, I'm super bearish on the US Dollar over the long term, but since everyone loves it right now, I am also bearish in the short and medium term too!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wow thats a big rise and a big drop in your funds performance.

    ReplyDelete
  6. p.s. Anonymous #1 - Foster is on ice just for you hehe! ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thx for the reply on the comments...what is ur view on TRY (Turkish Lira) Especially vs EUR. Market has been shorting EURTRY for the last few weeks (end of December 2011) seems that some people have been caught wrong footed after the spike in EURUSD.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I have actually been following the Turkish Lira a lot as of late, because it has been one of the weakest currencies of 2011 and there have been many reports of excessive hedge fund shorts in that market. Where ever there are large shorts, there is usually a potential to be wrong.

    Personally, to me it looks as if the Lira has bottomed against the Euro back in October - during the global currency panic. At the same time, the USD has been rallying hard against the Lira since November 2010, but now also looks to be topping - in other words the Lira could be in a progress of bottoming since December 2011.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thx for the reply Tiho...have a nice weekend ahead mate

    ReplyDelete
  10. Is anyone having trouble viewing the comment pages using IE?

    Recently when it loads for me I cannot scroll down. It's OK in Chrome.

    ReplyDelete
  11. "Since 1980 population has doubled, GDP has gone up 5 times, Dow Jones is up 12 times, Gold has more than doubled and Silver is down 40%."

    Tiho,
    What prices/currency are you using for those comparisions?

    For example in USD, Gold has doubled but silver is 50% higher.

    ReplyDelete
  12. In 1980, Gold hit $850 and Silver hit $50.

    Today Gold is at $1,600 plus, while Silver is around $30.

    ReplyDelete
  13. p.s. in 1980 Dow Jones was at 1,000 while today it is close to 13,000!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Tiho,
    I realise what I've done. I've looked at the average price for 1980 on Kitco which is only just over $20.
    http://www.kitco.com/scripts/hist_charts/yearly_graphs.plx
    Of course it did reach $48 in 1980 similar to the high last year.

    Good day for silver today!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Therefore, we can conclude that Silver is still some 35% to 40% below its all time high reached in 1980, without even adjusting that to inflation. On the other hand Gold has doubled from its 1980 all time high. So I would rather own Solver than Gold anyway!

    p.s. Yes it was a very nice day.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Tiho,
    So I suppose another way of looking at it, is that you have put 80% of your fund into something that is historically proven to perform poorly against practically anything else?

    It must increase massively because this time it's different? Of course you aren't forced to stay in it and can switch when you think the time is right. Do you have any idea of a timescale for how long you might stay in it?

    The markets are going to go down a bit now then rise through the summer. Do you think silver will follow the stock markets?

    ReplyDelete
  17. Yes, that is correct. I have placed 80% of my fund into something that has been relatively under performing and is currently in a secular uptrend. That is a perfect way to invest for me personally (up to you what you do), because the last thing I want to do is buy something that has been outperforming already. The gains have already happened, you understand.

    It has nothing to do with "this time is different" concept. Silver rose 50 times during the last secular uptrend, so it has proven many times it can move by a huge amount. Currently it is only up 6 times during the current secular uptrend. So, in my view, it has a huge potential to outperform, since it has been a major under performer. Do you understand the concept or thinking process I have here?

    Personally for me, investing is common sense, it is just that common sense is not that common.

    Finally, my view on the stock market can be read in previous Stocks updates here and here. Sure, Silver and Equities can sometimes correlate, but my outlook has no major link between the two. It might or might not happen.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Tiho,
    Me again.

    Don't get me wrong, I am not negative about silver, just looking for more justification. Indeed I have already followed you in. I was already thinking of buying and it was clear from your earlier posts that you were going to go long silver. So I decided to let you decide when I bought. I lined up some money and pressed some buttons when you went long. Though I haven't used your PSLV, which I hope isn't my downfall.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Previous posts show Tiho has consistency at bottom ticking market falls. If you buy when he buys, you stand above average chance.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Tiho, are you sure you're not a trader? Usually only traders buy front-month options :)

    In all seriousness, I am also short the overall market at the moment. I am mostly focused on the tech sector because sentiment seems most bullish there - among newsletter writers especially. My short weapon of choice (when I can get it) is shorting leveraged ETFs, so I can benefit from the decay factor. Sometimes it's hard to find shares to short, though. Right now it's super easy for me to find shares to short, probably because there is a disproportionately large amount of money in leveraged ETFs at the moment (another bearish indicator in itself?).

    ReplyDelete
  21. Am I sure? Well, look at it this way: my put options on the stock market are in my personal account for a short term correction- which account for 0.00001% of my capital, while 99.9% of my money is invested in my fund. So yeah, I am sure.

    Regarding markets: I'm not too bearish on stocks, all I expect is a correction. If I had to short anything, I'd short Treasury Bonds instead, including the Long Bond.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Tiho,
    You have gone long the CHF is that also long this FXF? I don't get how it works.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Yes I am long Swiss Francs through an ETF called FXF. You can also do it buy shorting USD/CHF or buying CHF futures. It is all quite similar really.

    ReplyDelete